The Jews You Deserve

A Modest Proposal for Effective Counter-Semitism

Daily Stormer Book Club Flyer, 2018

Like the weather, people talk a great deal about the Jews without ever doing anything. They post Happy Merchant memes. They complain (I’d say kvetch but, you know…) about Jewish world domination. If they’re especially ambitious, they may even post some flyers or vandalize a synagogue or two. But nothing ever happens because nobody, including the posters and complainers, expects anything to happen.

There’s no shortage of anti-Semitic anger, but there’s a lack of purpose. All these spicy memes and sticker operations blow off steam and express displeasure, but there’s no end goal. Advertising executives know exactly what they want to do when they design ad campaigns. These acts lack a message other than “I Hate Jews, and You Should Too.” To that end, here are some thoughts on how we might more productively harness that energy.

The NaXalt Curse

This is one of the things that is easily said: "The Jewish people are going to be exterminated," that's what every Party member says, "sure, it's in our program, elimination of the Jews, extermination - it'll be done."

And then they all come along, the 80 million worthy Germans, and each one has his one decent Jew. Of course, the others are swine, but this one, he is a first-rate Jew. Of all those who talk like that, not one has seen it happen, not one has had to go through with it.

Most of you men know what it is like to see 100 corpses side by side, or 500 or 1,000. To have stood fast through this - and except for cases of human weakness - to have stayed decent, that has made us hard.

Heinrich Himmler, October 4, 1943

Complaints about ethnic disparities are frequently met with the objection “Not all X are like that.” This annoys ethnonationalists greatly, and with some reason. Typically what the objector really means is “No X are like that.” It’s a cheap dodge aimed at preserving social status rather than an actual engagement with the issues at hand.

That being said, there’s a reason Himmler had trouble finding people who were willing to move beyond NaXalt. It’s because most of us know that not all X are like that. We’ve all met sober Irishmen, law-abiding Black folks, Indians who use toilets, and Jews who don’t sacrifice babies to Moloch. Operation Reinhard was kept secret to avoid an inevitable outcry from 80 million tender-hearted German cucks.

Given all that, it’s a pretty safe bet that “Gas The Kikes Race War Now” stickers will only appeal to a limited audience. And considering that Himmler had access to a much larger support network than we do, the idea of fixing the Jewish problem with a Really This Time We Mean It Final Solution looks even more impractical.

Small-scale attacks have also proven ineffectual. Did Robert Bowers spark a wave of Jew-hatred when he attacked the Tree of Life synagogue? Was Dylann Roof the opening shot in a race war? How many mosques burned in New Zealand after Brenton Tarrent and how many communists were run out of Norway after Anders Brevik? From where I stand, it looks like their greatest achievements were providing the ADL with fundraising opportunities.

If you want to make meaningful changes, you’re going to need something more than spicy memes, fap fantasies, and temper tantrums. So where do we start?

But Enough Anti-Semitism … Here’s Some Racism

“Coon Coon Black Baboon” by A. Wyatt Mann

White Nationalists constantly condemn (one might say “hollers day and night”) the Black refusal to take responsibility for their situation. But yet many of those same nationalists constantly blame de Jew fo dey plight.

It’s the Jew pushes porn onto my PC.
It’s the Jew makes me watch that Woke TV.
He force us White folks to smoke that meth
And abort our babies for total White death

I’m not denying the existence of Racism or anti-Goyism. I’m simply stating that using it as an excuse for your failures is counterproductive. This mindset ensures that your opponent will forever be on top while you stay firmly stuck at the bottom. Complaining to the choir does nothing but make you feel better about your lot. Unless you do something about your problems, you’re just another loser palming off responsibility to someone else.

Note that the Jews you despise combine their constant complaining with effective direct actions against their opposition. Also note that many Black activists have dedicated their lives to fighting crime, poverty, and other community issues. (And no, that activism is not limited to “gibs me dat money fo dem programs.”) Since you’re genetically superior to Tyrone and Shlomo, what’s holding you back?

“The Jews” are a nebulous target that encompasses everybody from Saul Alinsky to Mark Zuckerberg, from Benjamin Netanyahu to Brother Nathanael. And one part of the problem starts with the way many anti-Semites determine who is or is not a Jew.

Behavior, Not Identity

Most modern anti-Semites rely on an ethnic definition of Jewishness. They simultaneously affirm that Jews are genetically tainted and that they’re really Khazars, not Jews. But historically anti-Semites saw the problem as Jewish culture, not Jewish blood. Wagner, no great fan of Jews, admired Hermann Levi enough to let him conduct the debut of Parsifal. He even urged him to convert to Christianity because he was spiritually a true German. (Levi politely declined).

Chaya Raichik, an Orthodox Jew, is one of our most effective campaigners against child sexualization. David Cole, a brilliant Jewish political strategist, believes the Holocaust actually happened. (It’s a long story). Israeli-born musician Gilad Atzmon has been a fierce critic of Zionism for decades.

There are many Jews who share our interests — or who inadvertently promote them. When it comes to promoting anti-Semitism on Substack, nobody does it better than Jeff Tiedrich. As Raichik has shown us, using your opponent’s most idiotic minions to discredit their cause works marvelously.

Tiedrich’s ethnicity is as plain as the … oh, never mind

When the Jewish Question hangs on tainted blood, we are stuck with an eternal enemy we can neither placate nor eradicate. Their efforts at assimilation can only be seen as subversion and their good deeds can only be interpreted as part of a grand plot toward Semitic Supremacy. When it hangs on bad behavior, we can work with both carrots and sticks. We can focus our efforts on evildoers and leave the rest alone so long as they return the favor. We can even work with like-minded Jews toward common ends.

If you’re about to explain how I’m a shabbos goy on the Mossad payroll, think first about what “purity spirals” have done for the Dissident Left. If you can only work with people who agree with you 100% and who have the proper ethnicity, you’re going to be drawing from a very small pool. Even worse, you’re going to push out your creative thinkers in favor of your sycophants and lickspittles. Are you in this to win or to be the One True National Socialist?

And Speaking of National Socialists

Most of today’s “Nazis” take their cues from Hollywood. This means that they model themselves after cartoon villains who may be comic or horrifying, but who inevitably lose in the final reel. It’s not surprising that these “Hollywood Nazis” have had little success in gaining political power. To paraphrase John Lennon, “If you go wavin’ round swastikas/You ain’t gonna make anyone join your cause.”

The original National Socialists weren’t scary or intimidating. They were clean-cut young men who helped little old ladies across the street and protected the citizens from Communist thugs and Jewish pimps and usurers. Its most violent street fighters, Ernst Röhm’s SA, got purged in a Night of the Long Knives when they became too embarrassing.

You can find lots of original NS material on Internet Archive in English and German. Instead of relying on fiction, pore through their ideas and see for yourself if you can find anything useful. If you find anything, rephrase it in your own words and present it as your own ideas. It’s not like anyone’s going to catch you. Our opponents refuse to read JK Rowling because of her bad politics. Do you think they’re going to pore through material written by the actual followers of the Original MC Adolf H?

Sure, they’re going to call you a Nazi. Everyone they don’t like is a Nazi. That once-grievous insult has lost a great deal of its sting. About the only way it’s going to do you any damage is if you self-identify as a loud, proud Nazi. Otherwise, you’re just another person whose politics are somewhere to the Right of Antonio Gramsci.

As the last survivors of World War II die off, Hitler is going to become much less frightening. 50 years from now, I anticipate that Hitler will be seen not as a figure of absolute evil but as an interesting political figure from the early to mid 20th century. I also anticipate that David Irving is going to be considered one of the few reliable Hitler biographers at that time. And I expect our current Nazi hysteria carries within it the seeds of that skepticism and critical inquiry. Which brings us to another topic.

Never Interrupt Your Enemy When He’s Making A Mistake

Many Dissident Right figures pride themselves on “naming the Jew.” But it’s considerably more effective when you let the Jew name himself. Here are some examples:

Pornography

“Many individuals in white supremacist communities have strong anti-porn sentiment,” Joshua Fisher-Birch, a researcher and content review specialist at the Counter Extremism Project told Vice. “There are numerous reasons for this, principally the beliefs that Jews control the porn industry, that it abuses and corrupts white women, normalizes interracial relationships, and disincentivizes procreation among whites. In many cases, porn is viewed as part of a Jewish-controlled anti-white conspiracy theory.”

Mira Fox, “The antisemitic conspiracy behind the anti-porn movement.” Forward (September 23, 2021)

George Soros

In far-right circles worldwide, Soros’ philanthropy often is recast as fodder for outsized conspiracy theories, including claims that he masterminds specific global plots or manipulates particular events to further his goals. Many of those conspiracy theories employ longstanding antisemitic myths, particularly the notion that rich and powerful Jews work behind the scenes, plotting to control countries and manipulate global events.

ADL, “The Antisemitism Lurking Behind George Soros Conspiracy Theories” (October 11, 2018)

Child Trafficking

The Dark Ages were rife with plague, fanaticism, and accusations that Jews secretly fed off the blood of children. In 2020, we too are beset with plague, rampant medical misinformation, and a persistent rumor that “global elites” torture children to harvest the chemical adrenochrome from their blood, which they then inject in order to stay healthy and young.

Brian Freidberg, “The Dark Virality of a Hollywood Blood-Harvesting Conspiracy” (Wired, July 31, 2020)

When you attack Jewishness directly, you provide evidence that Jews are under attack by anti-Semites. This leads to Jews, who have a high in-group preference, circling their wagons. When you attack issues, you force them into a place where they must either talk about the problem or defend the indefensible.

This approach is especially effective in light of the growing distaste for Israeli apartheid and genocide. Zionist supporters have used accusations of “anti-Semitism” as a club to discredit pro-Palestinian voices. But as the boy who cried wolf learned to his disadvantage, sooner or later people stop believing you — even when you’re telling the truth.

Focusing on behavior also lets you target your campaign more effectively. You don’t hate Jews, you hate pedophiles. And the louder your opponents scream that anti-pedophilia is anti-Semitism, the more firmly they cement the idea that Jews are complicit in the crimes you describe.

A Note to my Long-Suffering Jewish Friends

The ongoing war in Gaza and the West Bank has definitely brought out a lot of anti-Jewish bigotry . But it’s also inspired a lot of justified criticism of Israeli excesses. When you dismiss that criticism as anti-Semitism, you dilute your brand. And since one of the loudest and most effective American blocs fighting for Palestinian rights is left-wing Jews, you’re going to run into a great deal of skepticism.

Is a turn toward WW II-style anti-Semitism possible? Certainly. But it won’t be triggered by America’s self-proclaimed Nazis. If Israel uses its nuclear weapons in a first strike, I expect it will be a pariah nation — or a shiny sheet of radioactive glass — soon thereafter. And I also expect a serious backlash against diaspora Jews. If you don’t want yellow stars and cattle cars, I’d advise you to stop stanning for Israel’s filthy genocidal war.

And while I’m not asking you to convert, it would be nice if you at least showed our Faith the same respect you show for Islam. Yes, I’m aware that most of your deference in that regard comes out of fear for your personal safety rather than any touching regard for brown people. Lots of Christians are aware of that. And they’re also starting to realize that blasphemers won’t stop their antics until those antics become unsafe.

The ADL and similar organizations are far more concerned about intermarriage and assimilation than they are about Nazis. They want you to distrust and fear your Gentile neighbors because that fear promotes tribal unity and keeps their coffers full. You’re being manipulated by people who don’t have your best interests at heart. I may be blunt, crude, and occasionally offensive. But I’d rather not see innocent people killed over their ethnicity. For me those deaths are a tragedy. For the ADL and its ilk, they’re a fundraising campaign. If you quit chasing anti-Semitic shadows, you’ll find that most of us are happy to live alongside you. If you persist, you may wind up creating the monster you fear.